Purification of Water — Slow vs Rapid Sand Filters, Chlorination, Residual Chlorine and Drinking-Water Standards

Written & medically reviewed by the Kinase Medical Team · Last reviewed

Quick Answer

Large-scale purification uses storage, filtration and disinfection. Slow sand filters are biological, relying on the schmutzdecke; rapid sand filters are physical, used after alum coagulation and cleaned by backwashing. Chlorine is dosed past the breakpoint so that free chlorine of at least 0.5 mg/L remains after 30 minutes, and at least 0.2 mg/L reaches the consumer.

How is water purified on a large scale?

Community water supplies rely on a multiple-barrier approach. WHO lists the control measures as pretreatment, coagulation, flocculation, sedimentation, filtration and disinfection. The textbook trio for exams is storage → filtration → chlorination, and each step removes a different share of the microbial and particulate load.

Stages of large-scale (municipal) purification
StageWhat happensKey point
Storage (off-stream reservoirs)Natural purification of the raw water before treatmentWHO lists off-stream storage as pretreatment that reduces the microbial, organic and particulate load
Coagulation and flocculationA coagulant (classically alum) is added; fine particles clump into flocsWHO: chemical coagulation is the most important step deciding how well later clarification and filtration work
SedimentationFlocs settle in a clarifierRemoves most turbidity before the filters
FiltrationSlow sand (biological) or rapid gravity sand (physical) filtersRemoves remaining particles, bacteria and protozoal cysts
DisinfectionUsually chlorinationKills remaining pathogens and leaves a residual to protect the distribution system
Disinfection Breakpoint ChlorinationWater-operator training college explains breakpoint chlorination — what happens to chlorine as it is added to water until a free residual appears.Video: American Water College · 4:42 · Watch on YouTube · Loads from YouTube (privacy-enhanced mode) only when you press play.
CAWST Technology Talk: The Biosand FilterWater and sanitation NGO shows how a household biosand filter — an intermittent slow sand filter with a biological layer — makes water safer to drink.Video: CAWST · 5:30 · Watch on YouTube · Loads from YouTube (privacy-enhanced mode) only when you press play.

What is the difference between slow sand and rapid sand filters?

This comparison is the single most-tested area of the topic. WHO's treatment annex sums up the core difference: slow sand filtration is essentially a biological process, whereas rapid gravity filters are physical treatment processes.

Slow sand vs rapid gravity sand filter (WHO Guidelines for Drinking-water Quality, Annex 5)
FeatureSlow sand filterRapid sand (gravity) filter
Main mechanismBiological — the schmutzdeckePhysical — straining and trapping of floc
Sand size (effective)Fine: 0.15–0.3 mmCoarser: 0.5–1.0 mm
Bed depth0.5–1.5 m0.6–2.0 m
Flow rate0.1–0.3 m3/m2·h4–20 m3/m2·h (many times faster)
PretreatmentBest for low-turbidity or pre-filtered waterMostly used to remove floc from coagulated water
Where impurities collectTop few centimetres of sandUpper layers of the bed
CleaningScraping — the top few centimetres of sand are removed and replaced periodicallyBackwashing with treated water, sometimes preceded by air scouring
Line diagram of a slow sand filter: raw water enters a tank, a deep layer of supernatant water sits over the sand filter bed, support gravel and drain tiles, and filtered water flows out through a control valve to a clearwell.
Slow sand filter: a deep layer of raw water stands over a fine sand bed and passes through it slowly. Purification happens mainly in the top few centimetres of sand, where the biological layer forms.Image: US Environmental Protection Agency, Public domain
Cutaway drawing of a rapid sand filter tank showing wash troughs above a layer of filter sand, graded gravel beneath it, and perforated lateral pipes on the filter floor fed by a cast-iron manifold.
Rapid (gravity) sand filter: coarser sand over graded gravel, with underdrain pipes and wash troughs. The troughs carry away dirty water when the bed is cleaned by backwashing - reverse flow - instead of scraping.Image: US Environmental Protection Agency, Public domain

What is the schmutzdecke (vital layer)?

The schmutzdecke (German for 'dirt layer'), also called the vital layer or biological layer, is a slimy film of microbes and their exopolymers that forms on the surface of a slow sand filter. WHO describes it as a biologically active layer that retains microbes and often leads to their inactivation and biodegradation. Turbidity and microorganisms are removed mainly in the top few centimetres of sand.

  • Removal improves as the filter matures and its biological layer develops (WHO).
  • Performance depends on the presence of the schmutzdecke, grain size, flow rate and operating conditions such as temperature and pH (WHO Table 7.7).
  • Scraping removes the clogged top few centimetres of sand, which are replaced periodically.
  • The household biosand filter is a small, intermittently dosed version of the same idea.
An open concrete filter bed seen from one end, with clear shallow water over sand whose surface is covered in a patchy brown film.
The schmutzdecke (vital layer) on a slow sand filter: a brownish biological film on the sand surface that traps and breaks down microbes. Removing this clogged top layer by scraping is how the filter is cleaned.Image: Olov.Eriksson, CC BY-SA 4.0

How does chlorination work — chlorine demand and breakpoint?

Chlorine — whether as gas, sodium hypochlorite or calcium hypochlorite — dissolves in water to form hypochlorous acid (HOCl) and hypochlorite ion (OCl−). Before any chlorine is left over to disinfect, some of it is used up by organic and inorganic matter.

  • Chlorine demand — the amount of chlorine consumed by chlorine-reactive substances in the water. It must be satisfied first.
  • Combined chlorine — chlorine bound to nitrogen compounds such as ammonia (chloramines); a weak disinfectant.
  • Free (residual) chlorine — chlorine left available for disinfection; it also protects water from recontamination.
  • Total chlorine = combined + free chlorine.

Breakpoint chlorination means adding enough chlorine to rapidly oxidise all the ammonia nitrogen and still leave a suitable free residual to protect water from the point of chlorination to the point of use. Chlorine that reacts with ammonia forms chloramines (combined chlorine), a weak disinfectant; only once that demand is met does added chlorine stay as free chlorine.

Chlorination techniques (WHO)
TechniqueWhat it meansWhen used
Marginal chlorinationSimple dosing to a desired free residualHigh-quality water with very low chlorine demand (a breakpoint may not even occur)
Breakpoint chlorinationDose enough to destroy ammonia and leave free residualStandard approach when ammonia or organic matter is present
Superchlorination–dechlorinationA large dose for rapid disinfection, then excess chlorine removedVariable bacterial load or too little contact time

How much residual chlorine should drinking water have?

WHO's guideline for chlorine reads: for effective disinfection there should be a residual concentration of free chlorine of ≥ 0.5 mg/L after at least 30 minutes' contact time at pH < 8.0, a residual should be maintained throughout the distribution system, and at the point of delivery the minimum free chlorine should be 0.2 mg/L. The health-based upper guideline value for free chlorine is 5 mg/L.

Residual chlorine targets to remember
PointValueSource
At the treatment plant after contact≥ 0.5 mg/L free chlorine after ≥ 30 min, pH < 8WHO GDWQ
At the consumer's tapMinimum 0.2 mg/L free chlorineWHO GDWQ; BIS IS 10500:2012
When protection against viral infection is neededMinimum 0.5 mg/L at the consumer endBIS IS 10500:2012 remark
Aesthetic upper comfort levelAbove about 1.5 mg/L water may be rejected for tasteWHO SEARO chlorination guide
Health-based guideline maximum5 mg/LWHO GDWQ

How is residual chlorine tested — OT test and Horrock's apparatus?

The classic Indian field test is the orthotoluidine (OT) test. Residual chlorine oxidises the orthotoluidine (orthotolidine) reagent in acid conditions, producing a yellow colour whose depth is matched against colour standards in a comparator. Because it reacts with chlorine, hypochlorous acid and chloramines alike, it measures total (free plus combined) chlorine. Indian dialysis-water guidance still uses an orthotoluidine reagent and comparator disc for routine chlorine checks.

  • OT test — yellow colour, total residual chlorine.
  • OTA (orthotoluidine-arsenite) test — a modification of the OT test listed in Indian emergency water guidance alongside the OT, thiosulphate and neutral red tests.
  • DPD test — the method WHO's chlorination guide now describes for most commercial kits; the sample turns pink if chlorine is present.

Horrock's apparatus (Horrock's water-testing case) is an old army field kit for working out how much bleaching powder a given water needs. A weak solution of bleaching powder is added in graded amounts to samples of the water, which are then tested for free chlorine. The result guides how much bleaching powder to add to the whole supply — in effect a field estimate of the water's chlorine demand.

A small water-testing kit: a glass sample tube beside a comparator card of yellow colour bands marked with chlorine levels, and a dropper bottle of orthotolidine reagent.
An orthotolidine comparator kit. The reagent turns the sample yellow in proportion to the residual chlorine, and the depth of colour is matched against the standards on the card.Image: Registreernu, CC0

What chlorine compounds are used, and how strong is bleaching powder?

Common chlorine sources (approximate active chlorine when fresh)
CompoundApproximate active chlorineNotes
Bleaching powder (chlorinated lime)About one-third — WHO SEARO quotes ~35%; textbooks quote 33%Strength falls with age and storage conditions (WHO SEARO)
High-test hypochlorite (calcium hypochlorite)~70%Concentrated powder; also degrades on storage
Sodium hypochlorite solutionCommonly 5%, 10% or 15%Liquid; 0.5–1% solutions are marketed for household water treatment
Sodium dichloroisocyanurate (NaDCC) tabletsReleases free chlorine on dissolvingHousehold and emergency use
Chlorine gasPure chlorineLarge treatment plants

How is water purified at household level?

Household water treatment options (WHO)
MethodHowStrengths and limits
BoilingBring to a rolling boil and let cool without adding iceWHO: simplest and most effective way to kill all pathogens, even in turbid water or at altitude; leaves no residual and does not remove turbidity
ChlorinationHousehold bleach, NaDCC tablets or calcium hypochloriteAt about 25 °C allow at least 30 minutes contact; double the time for each 10 °C colder; leaves a residual
FiltrationCeramic, cloth/fibre, membrane or biosand filtersBiosand relies on a biological layer; ceramic and cloth filters are poor at removing viruses
Solar disinfection (SODIS)Clear plastic bottles exposed to sunlightWorks through UV plus heat; depends on sunlight, turbidity and container depth

What are the key drinking-water quality standards?

Both WHO and the Bureau of Indian Standards set the same bacteriological rule: E. coli or thermotolerant coliform bacteria must not be detectable in any 100 mL sample of water intended for drinking. For treated water entering or in the distribution system, total coliforms must also be undetectable in any 100 mL sample.

Selected limits from BIS IS 10500:2012 (acceptable / permissible in absence of an alternate source)
ParameterAcceptable limitPermissible limit
E. coli / thermotolerant coliformsNot detectable in any 100 mLNo relaxation
pH6.5–8.5No relaxation
Turbidity1 NTU5 NTU
Total dissolved solids500 mg/L2,000 mg/L
Fluoride1.0 mg/L1.5 mg/L
Nitrate (as NO3)45 mg/LNo relaxation
Free residual chlorine (minimum, at consumer end)0.2 mg/L1 mg/L

What are the common exam traps in water purification?

  1. Schmutzdecke / vital layer belongs to the slow sand filter, not the rapid one.
  2. Rapid sand filters need coagulation (alum) first and are cleaned by backwashing.
  3. Slow sand filtration is biological; rapid sand filtration is physical.
  4. Free residual chlorine: ≥ 0.5 mg/L after 30 min (WHO) at the plant; ≥ 0.2 mg/L at the tap.
  5. Chlorine demand must be satisfied before any free residual appears — that point is the breakpoint.
  6. OT test gives a yellow colour and measures total chlorine; DPD gives pink.
  7. Bleaching powder is about one-third available chlorine and is unstable on storage.
  8. Chlorine is unreliable against *Cryptosporidium* — filtration is needed.
  9. Drinking water: zero E. coli or thermotolerant coliforms per 100 mL.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a slow sand filter and a rapid sand filter?
A slow sand filter uses fine sand and works biologically through the schmutzdecke, filtering only 0.1 to 0.3 cubic metres per square metre per hour and cleaned by scraping the top layer. A rapid sand filter uses coarser sand, works physically on water that has been coagulated with alum, filters 4 to 20 cubic metres per square metre per hour and is cleaned by backwashing.
What is the schmutzdecke?
The schmutzdecke, or vital layer, is the biologically active film of microorganisms and their slime that forms on the surface of a slow sand filter. It traps microbes and often inactivates and breaks them down, so most turbidity and pathogens are removed in the top few centimetres of sand. Performance depends on this layer, sand grain size and flow rate.
What is breakpoint chlorination?
Breakpoint chlorination means adding enough chlorine to satisfy the water's chlorine demand and oxidise all the ammonia nitrogen, so that any further chlorine stays as free residual chlorine. Chlorine bound to ammonia forms weak chloramines; the free chlorine left beyond the breakpoint protects the water from the point of chlorination to the point of use.
How much residual chlorine should be present in drinking water?
WHO recommends free chlorine of at least 0.5 mg/L after at least 30 minutes of contact at pH below 8 for effective disinfection, with at least 0.2 mg/L remaining at the point of delivery. BIS IS 10500 also sets 0.2 mg/L as the minimum at the consumer end, rising to 0.5 mg/L when protection against viral infection is needed.
What is the orthotoluidine test?
The orthotoluidine (OT) test is a simple colour test for residual chlorine. The reagent is oxidised by chlorine, hypochlorous acid and chloramines, giving a yellow colour that is compared against standards in a comparator. Because it reacts with both forms, it measures total chlorine. Indian guidance also lists an orthotoluidine-arsenite (OTA) variant.
How much available chlorine does bleaching powder contain?
Fresh bleaching powder, or chlorinated lime, contains about one-third available chlorine; textbooks quote 33 percent and WHO's South-East Asia chlorination guide gives about 35 percent. Its strength falls with age and poor storage, so old stock should be assumed weaker when calculating a dose. High-test hypochlorite contains about 70 percent.
What is the best way to purify water at home?
WHO states that bringing water to a rolling boil is the simplest and most effective way to kill all disease-causing organisms, even in turbid water. Boiling leaves no residual, so water must be stored safely afterwards. Alternatives include chlorine tablets or bleach with at least 30 minutes of contact, ceramic or biosand filters, and solar disinfection.
What is the bacteriological standard for drinking water?
Under both WHO guidelines and BIS IS 10500, Escherichia coli or thermotolerant coliform bacteria must not be detectable in any 100 mL sample of drinking water. Treated water entering or flowing through the distribution system must also show no total coliforms in any 100 mL sample. E. coli is used because it indicates faecal contamination.

Sources

  1. WHO — Guidelines for Drinking-water Quality, 4th edition incorporating the 1st and 2nd addenda (2022)
  2. WHO SEARO — Principles and Practices of Drinking-water Chlorination (2017)
  3. BIS — IS 10500:2012 Drinking Water Specification (Second Revision), Public.Resource.Org copy
  4. Kumar A. Ensuring safe water in post-chemical, biological, radiological and nuclear emergencies. J Pharm Bioallied Sci 2010 (PMC3148630)
  5. Electrolytic hydrogen-generating bottle and residual chlorine by orthotolidine colorimetry. Med Gas Res 2021 (PMC8130662)
  6. Indian Journal of Nephrology 2020 — Hemodialysis guidelines, Chapter 4: Water Treatment (PMC7598397)
  7. Water Supply on Active Service — Horrock's water-testing cases. The Hospital 1919 (PMC5252232)

For exam preparation and education only — not a substitute for clinical judgement or local guidelines. How we write and review these pages: editorial policy.

Revise Purification of Water with questions

Kinase: NEET-PG & INICET has previous-year papers, a subject-wise QBank and Grand Tests with explanations — on Android, iOS and the web.