A 3-year-old girl is brought in crying after her father lifted her by the wrist to stop her stepping onto a road. She now holds the arm slightly bent with the forearm turned palm-down and will not move it, yet there is no swelling or deformity and plain radiographs of the elbow are reported as normal. What is the most likely diagnosis?
- A.Supracondylar fracture
- B.Elbow dislocation
- C.Radial head subluxation
- D.Monteggia fracture-dislocation
Show answer and explanation
Answer: C. Radial head subluxation
Correct answer: C. Radial head subluxation. The history of a sudden longitudinal pull on a young child with a pronated, guarded arm and normal films is classic for a pulled elbow.
This is radial head subluxation (pulled elbow, nursemaid elbow). A quick axial traction on the extended, pronated forearm lets the annular ligament slip up over the radial head and become trapped in the radiocapitellar joint. Because it is a soft-tissue slip and not a fracture, plain radiographs are typically normal. Reduction is achieved by supination with elbow flexion or by hyperpronation, after which the child rapidly uses the arm again.
The annular ligament encircles the radial head; a sudden axial pull lets it slip over the head.
Incorrect Options:
- A. Supracondylar fracture: a distal humeral fracture that typically follows a fall on an outstretched hand and shows a fracture line, an effusion or a displaced fat pad on radiographs, none of which are present here.
Supracondylar fracture: a distal humeral break usually visible on radiographs.
- B. Elbow dislocation: produces obvious deformity, marked swelling and clear radiographic malalignment, which is not the picture in a well-looking child with normal films.
Elbow dislocation: gross loss of joint alignment on the radiograph.
- D. Monteggia fracture-dislocation: combines a proximal ulnar fracture with dislocation of the radial head and is clearly abnormal on radiographs, unlike this benign presentation.
Monteggia injury: proximal ulnar fracture with radial head dislocation.
High-Yield Facts:
- Peak age is roughly 1 to 4 years; the annular ligament is thin and lax at this age.
- The arm is held pronated and slightly flexed, with pain but no swelling or deformity.
- Radiographs are usually normal; imaging is mainly to exclude fracture when the story is atypical.
- Hyperpronation is often more successful and less painful than supination-flexion for reduction.
